ESCAP: Supervised Exercise for Patients With Coronary Heart Disease in the Primary Care Setting

Effectiveness of the Supervised Exercise for Patients With Coronary Heart Disease in the Primary Care Setting (ESCAP): a Randomized Clinical Trial

Preventive Services and Health Promotion Research Network, Castilla-La Mancha Health Service, Castilla-León Health Service, Dalt Sant Joan primary care center (Balears Islans Health Service), Public Health Service of Cataluña, Public Health Service of Madrid, Public Health Service of Galicia, Cantabria Health Service

In Spain, family physician are currently recommended to prescribe an unsupervised walking program to their coronary heart disease (CHD) patients as a part of their cardiac rehabilitation program. However, there are a few family physicians who provide their CHD patients with supervised exercise (30 minutes of pedaling on an stationary bicycle at 60-85% of the peak heart rate (HR) attained at the maximal or symptom limited treadmill test, 3 times a week) at their primary care health centers, thinking that these patients improve their functional capacity, quality of life, and the control of cardiovascular risk factors, more than walking because they can not achieve the ideal exercise intensity for maximal benefits by walking. This study has been designed to investigate if CHD patients get more health benefits with the supervised exercise program at the health center than with the unsupervised walking program.

In order to obtain the maximal health benefits, CHD patients have to attain an exercise intensity between 60 and 85% of the maximal or symptom-limited heart rate (HR). This is not currently attained by the patients who are prescribed an unsupervised walking program. The OBJECTIVE of this randomized clinical trial is to investigate if CHD patients improve their functional capacity and quality of life more, and control their cardiovascular risk factors better, by coming to their health centers to pedal during 30 minutes on an stationary bicycle , 3 or more times a week, with a HR monitor which makes sure that they attain HRs within the prescribed interval, and supervised by health personal, than by walking without supervision. For that purpose, low risk CHD patients from 11 Spanish health centers will be randomly assigned to a supervised exercise group (ESCAP) or to another unsupervised walking group (control). Both groups will be also provided with health education and the corresponding treatment for cardiovascular risk factor control and complication prevention by their family physicians. The average changes observed in the two groups will be compared, on the basis of intention to treat through analysis of covariance. We will use mixed-effect models to take into account intra-patients and intra-center correlation.

Primary Health Care, Family Practice, Family Physician, Exercise, Coronary Heart Disease, Randomized Controlled Trials, Multicenter Studies

Supervised exercise on a stationary bicycle, 3-5 days a week, plus a secondary prevention program for coronary heart disease

Inclusion Criteria: Coronary heart disease low risk patients Under 80 years old Exclusion Criteria: 80 years of age and over Patients included in cardiac rehabilitation programs Moderate and high risk patients Patients with handicaps for exercising Patients unable to attend the supervised exercise sessions Unstable angina Uncontrolled atrial ventricular arrhythmias Third degree AV block (without pacemaker) Uncompensated congestive heart failure Severe aortic stenosis Suspected or known dissecting aneurysm Active myocarditis or pericarditis Thrombophlebitis Recent embolism Acute systemic illness or fever Significant emotional distress (psychosis) Orthostatic blood pressure drop of >20 mm Hg with symptoms Uncontrolled sinus tachycardia Resting ST segment displacement (>2 mm) Uncontrolled diabetes (resting blood glucose >400 mg/dl) Other metabolic problems such as acute thyroiditis, hypo or hyperkalemia, hypovolemia, etc. Resting SBP>200 mm Hg or resting DBP>110 mm Hg

Ortega Sanchez-Pinilla R. [Differences in intensity of effort between supervised and non-supervised exercise of patients with ischaemic cardiopathy]. Aten Primaria. 2004 Sep 30;34(5):265-6. doi: 10.1016/s0212-6567(04)70847-1. No abstract available. Spanish.

Ortega R, Garcia-Ortiz L, Torcal J, Echevarria P, Vargas-Machuca C, Gomez A, Salcedo F, Lekuona I, Montoya I, Grandes G; ESCAP Group. Supervised exercise for acute coronary patients in primary care: a randomized clinical trial. Fam Pract. 2014 Feb;31(1):20-9. doi: 10.1093/fampra/cmt059. Epub 2013 Oct 19.